Mehaffies Pies

Mehaffies Pies is a Dayton bakery that has been making fruit pies, cream pies and cheesecakes since 1930. The bakery produces more than 45 flavors of pies and cheesecakes daily, and its New York-style cheesecake has become a favorite alongside the pies. Production is limited each day to keep quality consistent.

The bakery is at 3013 Linden Ave in Dayton and is open Monday through Saturday, with orders placed through its online ordering page. Mehaffies also supplies pies and cheesecakes for fundraisers through the Pie Peddler program, which serves schools and nonprofits within about 125 miles of Dayton.