Batavia Creamery

Batavia Creamery is an ice cream shop known for its scoops, shakes, malts, smoothies, floats, and sundaes. The menu includes 44 flavors on any day with over 200 rotating, and the Ice Cream Flights let guests pick any six flavors to share or take home. Ice cream pies such as Turtle, Oreo, and Cookie Dough are a store favorite, and the shop also makes custom ice cream cakes and keeps 25 to 30 ready to go.

The shop offers catering, pints and quarts, and gift cards, and it accepts online orders. Hours run daily, with later evening closings on Friday and Saturday. Vegan and oat options carry an extra charge. The shop is at 4 N Island Ave in Batavia.