Papis Creamery

Papi's Creamery makes small-batch ice cream with a Mexican and American twist, blending bold flavors like Mango Tres Leches and Chocolate Fluffernutter. Recipes are made in-house with real ingredients, and each pint is handpacked in layers with swirls and crunchy mix-ins.

The menu rotates weekly, so flavors change from one week to the next. Orders go live on Thursdays at 7 pm, and customers pick up their pints at the shop during a selected pickup window. The creamery is at 2900 Hampton Hwy in Yorktown, and party orders and flavor suggestions can be sent through its contact form.