Casa Maya

Casa Maya is a Mexican restaurant and seafood and tequila bar on Hypolita Street in downtown St. Augustine. Diners mention the seafood paella, which comes with saffron rice and is served for two, along with the cochinita pibil, chicken quesadillas and octopus ceviche. The menu also includes Mexican dishes like huevos rancheros, and the bar serves handcrafted cocktails.

Reservations can be booked online, and the restaurant also takes online food orders and handles catering for parties and events. Private groups are seated in an upstairs dining room on the second floor of a renovated older building, which has no elevator access. Live music is sometimes played on the patio in the evenings, and gift cards are available.