Mustache Bill's

Mustache Bill's is a classic diner built around a dining car on Broadway in Barnegat Light. Guests can eat inside the car or in an enclosed patio, and the full menu is posted online as a multi-page PDF.

The diner is open on Saturdays and Sundays only. Parties check in with the host on arrival, are added to a wait list, and wait outside until their name is called. For takeout, call the to-go line before 11 AM or after 1 PM, and orders are ready in about 30 minutes. Bring cash, since the diner doesn't take cards. The building is also listed for sale or lease.